Public Policy: Evaluation

Identify

1. Identify sections of the  research article that will provide information that you need. 
   1. Abstract/Introduction (background, question, research problem)
   2. Methodology (approach, methods, instruments)
   3. Data/Conclusion (Results)

Summarize

1. What is the problem or question?
2. What is their approach to research?
3. How are they going about answering the question?
4. What did they conclude?

Evaluate

1. Credibilty
   1. Does the research question seem clear?
   2. Does it seem like a question that can be answered? With their approach?
   3. Are the methods sound? (population not too small, controls, etc)
2. Reliability
   1. Are the methods clear enough that the experiment/research could be reproduced?
3. Authority
   1. Is the author(s) affiliated with a research institution?
   2. What other publications have the author(s) published?
   3. How many times have they been cited?
4. Bias/Point of view
   1. Is there any potential conflict of interest?
   2. Who funded the study?

• HOW TO CRITICALLY EVALUATE THE QUALITY OF A RESEARCH ARTICLE

  Advice for students from graduate students in psychology

• Critical Appraisal of Scientific Articles

  Focuses on science and medicine